At Survivor Series, an 8-man elimination match took place withsix of the eight participants being little people. There have been 218 matches awarded 5 or more stars; Mitsuharu Misawa and Will Ospreay are tied for the most individual matches with 25 apiece. Vince McMahon seized the perfect opportunity to turn one of those dream feuds into a reality when he booked HBK to face Kurt Angle on the grandest stage of them all. Dave Meltzer, who began watching professional wrestling at age 9, has been putting out The Wrestling Observer as a weekly since 1986. 4.0 out of 5 stars 24. RELATED: Kenny Omega's 10 Best Matches, According To Dave Meltzer. The bout truly deserves five stars for the incredible story it told. . By Dave Meltzer, Wrestling Observer Sep 27, 2021. However, lately, Meltzer often gives five stars to some matches that clearly don't deserve that perfect rating. Keiji Muto si ritirato allo show sotto il nome di Grand Final Pro-Wrestling "Last" Love, andiamo a vedere i voti di Dave Meltzer. Andrew Kelly is a writer from The Wirral, England. RELATED: 5 Kenny Omega Matches Dave Meltzer Overrated (& 5 He Underrated). The match itself was great too, with great sequences and drama, but it was the story that carried this match to the rating it received from Meltzer. Whilst his ratings are subjective, they often highlight the general consensus on the best of the best when it comes to individual wrestlers. Whilst the result wasnt really in doubt, the four men did enough to get the crowd rocking for this tremendous title bout. Since 1983, Meltzer has been the publisher and editor of the Wrestling Observer . Professional wrestling journalist and sports historian Dave Meltzer has assigned ratings to professional wrestling events since the creation of his publication, the Wrestling Observer Newsletter in 1982, and named his first 5-star match in 1983. This is a list of both active and inactive Wrestling Observer Newsletter awards created by professional wrestling and mixed martial arts (MMA) journalist Dave Meltzer.The first fourteen awards were created in 1980 as an informal poll between Meltzer and his friends and others he corresponded with on the subject of professional wrestling at the time. When the two finally met at the Hardcore Evening Gown Match, one of the weirdest matches in WWEs history took place. Whilst their feud to that point had been a mess, this nearly made up for all the bad booking. 4, Dynamite #40 - Fyter Fest 2020: Night 2 Taping, The New Beginning in Sapporo 2020 - Day 2, Raising an Army Memorial Series '17 - Day 4, Summer Navigation 2017 ~ 11th Global Junior Heavyweight Tag League - Day 8, 15th Anniversary Kobe Pro-Wrestling Festival 2014, Bridge Of Dreams ~ Dome Spring Full Bloom, no countout no disqualification "streak vs. career". Truth be told, Dave Meltzer should have seen another match, because this one didn't deserve four and a half stars. Dave Meltzer definitely over rated this match. It could be argued that Meltzers rating for this match was a little too high, as it certainly wasnt completely perfect, with some very slow moments and a predictable nature, but it was still a very enjoyable battle for the Tag Team Titles. Vince McMahon wanted to inject WWE with a lethal dose of poison so he brought the nWO to do his bidding. Roberth Prez is a journalist extremely passionate about sports and its stats. Wrestling Observer Radio: Remembering Lanny Poffo, Fedor, NXT Vengeance Day . It was a stunning show of psychology to carry a match for that long, which is certainly difficult to do for nearly an hour. Potential Buyer Pulls Out Of Race To Purchase WWE? Apart from lasting a mere 43 seconds, the match did not feature a professional referee - something that was weirdly allowed back then and something that would be unheard of today. This was an interpromotional "champion versus champion" match in which Kenny Omega put the AEW World Title on the line while Rich Swann defended the Impact World Title. Receiving a 5 or higher star rating is considered by many to be a great achievement. The World's Most Entertaining Car Website. Amongst their classic trilogy, Steamboat and Flair worked the house show circuit, with this match in March standing out as one of the few matches to break Dave Meltzers 5 Star Rating, by achieving an astonishing 6 Stars. This match was quite entertaining, of course, but frankly, this is not what one expects from a four star match. Professional wrestling journalist and sports historian Dave Meltzer has assigned ratings to professional wrestling events since the creation of his publication, the Wrestling Observer Newsletter in 1982, and named his first 5-star match in 1983. The wrestling promoters booked the show and in hundreds of closed-circuit locations around the country. Because of the poor ratings, the Kennel from Hell has never been featured again. Following their one-hour time limit draw, this was a much-anticipated rematch between Adam Page and Bryan Danielson. A five-star match should be exceptional, flawless, perfect, a masterpiece, simply an all-time classic. Finn Blor e Rhea Ripley vs. There are some names that appear multiple times too, standing out as the top performers in the promotion since its birth back in 2019. The two superstars told an incredible story as they stayed inside the ring for the whole duration of the match. This was an incredibly historic match, although the rating itself may be solely due to how good the concept of the War Games match was, rather than the in-ring quality itself. It could also mean more higher quality matches are in Japan, and if you understand the culture of the fans and wrestlers, because of the emphasis on skills, that logically would be the case. WWE: The 10 Worst Wrestling Matches Ever (According To Dave Meltzer), The Royal FamilyVs. Clowns R' Us (-2.5/10), The Boogeyman & Little BoogeymanVs. Finlay & Little Bastard (-3/10), Goldust Vs. 85. Despite their incredible status in the eyes of many wrestling fans, however, neither of the two matches have had the privilege of receiving the five star label from Dave Meltzer; whose opinion on the subject is considered an authority by a large section of wrestling fans in spite of his very own admission that the ratings system reflects his personal take on the overall match quality. One of the most exciting aspects of watching a wrestling Pay-Per-View, or a Premium Live Event, as WWE calls it, is giving every . Whilst it wasnt quite as good as their previous match, it felt like it had more urgency and intensity at times, and it was still a brilliant title fight. Apart from the two fighters running out of gas early in the match, the boxing format of the match made it more painful to watch. News on all your favorite celebs, reality TV, and movies. It was too long and boring, with lousy performances overall. Make Yahoo Your Homepage Discover something new every day from News, Sports, Finance, Entertainment . Privacy Policy. The entire match was slow and lasted for less than six minutes, and its poor entertainment value had nothing to do with the lack of gimmicks in this otherwise traditional wrestling bout. This match is simply one of the most annoying and insulting events in the history of professional wrestling. The Lucha Brothers picked up the victory to a huge reaction too. The effects of Vince McMahon retiring from WWE in the wake of his personal scandal are just beginning to be felt within the company, but the impact of new leadership headed by Stephanie McMahon, Nick Khan and Paul "Triple H" Levesque will pose "a big, big challenge" for AEW. Dave Meltzer's History of Pro Wrestling on Thanksgiving. While his match against Triple H was one of his worst performances, its the tie against Goldust that would be the final straw to his illustrious career, and WWE would release the Ultimate Warrior from his contract four months after his return. It was compiled by Dave Meltzer and published in the wrestling observer in 2008. Unique lists featuring pop culture, entertainment and crazy facts. Whilst this was just as long as some of their other encounters, it was wrestled at a much quicker and determined pace, which resulted in Flair scoring the victory to retain the World Heavyweight Championship. Some of these matches were so terrible that they even received negative ratings from critics. Flair ruled the 80s when it came to perfect scores with all but one of his 5+ star matches taking place in the decade. 10 Wrestling Matches Dave Meltzer Over Rated, The Inner Circle Vs. American Top Team & Men Of The Year - AEW Full Gear 2021 (4 Stars), Brock Lesnar Vs. Dean Ambrose vs. Roman Reigns Fastlane 2016 (4 Stars), Kenny Omega Vs. Rich Swann - Impact Wrestling Rebellion 2021 (4 Stars), Bobby Roode Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura - WWE NXT TakeOver: Orlando (4 Stars), Kota Ibushi Vs. SANADA - NJPW G1 Climax 2019 (4 Stars), Kazuchika Okada Vs. SANADA - NJPW Wrestling Dontaku 2019 (4 Stars), Jeff Cobb Vs. Kazuchika Okada - NJPW Wrestle Grand Slam In MetLife Dome (4 Stars), Marty Jannetty Vs. Shawn Michaels Monday Night Raw (4 Stars), Bandido Vs. Dragon Lee - PWG Battle Of Los Angeles 2019 (5 Stars), Christian Cage & The Jurassic Express Vs. RELATED: Kenny Omega's 10 Best Matches, According To Dave Meltzer Flair is undoubtedly one of the greatest of all time, and although his career has gone on far longer than it should (on more than . After a great match prior to this which saw a title change, the stakes were heightened as this was a Two out of Three Falls Match, which lasted for nearly a whole hour. The first match in All Elite Wrestling history to receive the hallowed five stars from Dave Meltzer was an absolute bloodbath between the Rhodes brothers. The company held the fourth iteration of the highly innovative match type on the October 7, 2002, edition of Monday Night RAW. Since the early 1980s, the name "Dave Meltzer" has been synonymous with wrestling journalism. Cookie Notice The SuperKliq AEW Full Gear 2021 (5 Stars), 10 Wrestlers You Won't Believe Never Got A 5-Star Rating From Dave Meltzer, he is giving five-star (or higher) ratings more often than ever, The story between Ambrose and Reigns was very interesting, The 10 Best Interpromotional Matches In AEW, So Far, 10 Things AEW Fans Need To Know About Kazuchika Okada, Shawn Michaels and Marty Jannetty had a great story, 10 Former Impact/TNA Wrestlers Who Surprisingly Are Still Wrestling, 10 Worst WWE Wrestlers To Compete For A World Championship At WrestleMania. Let's review Flair's best matches, according to Dave Meltzer of the Wrestling Observer! However, when these two superstars finally met, the result was anything but pleasing to the eye since it involved Andre the Giant leaning on the ropes and Hogan doing what little he could with that. Frankly, the match was pretty good, but it was nowhere near deserving of a four and a half star rating. According to Meltzer it was .25 less than perfect ( 4.75 was the official rating). The Ultimate Warrior (-3.5/10), Every Match Dave Meltzer Gave 5 Stars, Ranked, WWE: 10 Wrestling Legends Who Were Terrible On The Microphone, Wrestlemania: The 5 Best (& 5 Worst) Tag Team Title Matches, Why WCW's Ring Was So Different From WWE's, Explained, 5 Best WWE Tag Team Champions Of The Golden Era (& 5 Worst). After months of incredible buildup, the two finally met at WrestleMania 21. Here are the match ratings for the show according to Dave Meltzer. Certainly, the match has very exciting sequences, but there were a couple of obvious botches and Rich Swann looked completely lost and exhausted at times, seemingly unable to keep up with Omega, who won the match and the Impact World Championship. Sometimes I Quit Matches can become tiresome in more modern days due to wrestlers constantly being asked if they want to quit, but this was done right as it felt like two men trying to kill each other. The American journalist Dave was born in 24th of October, 1959 in the Empire State New York, USA. Despite how great it was, the match received 4.75 stars from Meltzer, who rated that night's iconic ladder match between Shawn Michaels and Razor Ramon five stars. Undeniably, this match was amazing, but it's hard to understand why Dave Meltzer rated it five stars. Dave Meltzer Star Ratings - Wrestlemania 10 (X) - Bret Hart vs. Owen Hart. dave the last few years you have acted as an anti-WWE and you have fed that hatred towards a company and certain pro wrestling fans who hate wwe have sheltered with you and that is why when you do an awards vote on your page it seems corrupted and bought by @TonyKhan Though Big Bossman managed to dominate the entire match, he did nothing interesting. Please note that this list only reflects matches entered into the database already and is therefore not necessarily a complete list. All credit goes to Meltzer for taking the time to make lists like this and please, if you haven't already, subscribe to the wrestling observer newsletter. On September 4, 2021, Jeff Cobb scored one of the biggest wins of his career by defeating Kazuchika Okada in a great bout, but it was nothing extraordinary as Dave Meltzer thinks it was. WWE bouts such as The Undertaker versus Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania 25, as well as the incredible triple threat main event of WrestleMania 20, have continued to receive widespread praise for their overall excellence. Davey Boy Smith, or The British Bulldog, was one of the great technical wizards of the '80s and '90s, wrestling great matches all across the world. Then general manager Stephanie McMahon pitted Benoit and Angle against Edge and Mysterio to determine the inaugural WWE Tag Team Champions. Can be found on Twitter @andrew_kelly0. This match would be perfectly fine with four stars. The Royal Family consists of Jerry the King Lawler and three mini-Lawlers, while the Clowns R' Us consists of Doink the Clown and three mini-Doinks. It was quite clear that this would not be an intense match-up, but one specifically created to humor and entertain the crowd. Published in the history of professional wrestling at age 9, has been synonymous with wrestling journalism was. Of professional wrestling at age 9, has been synonymous with wrestling.! Story as they stayed inside the ring for the show and in hundreds of closed-circuit locations around the country the! And Bryan Danielson Hardcore Evening Gown match, because this one did n't four... As they stayed inside the ring for the whole duration of the wrestling Observer, edition of Night... A mess, this was a much-anticipated rematch between Adam Page and Bryan Danielson and in of! Exceptional, flawless, perfect, a masterpiece, simply an all-time classic taking. Professional wrestling at age 9, has been the publisher and editor of the weirdest in... Should have seen another match, because this one did n't deserve that perfect rating receiving 5! Radio: Remembering Lanny Poffo, Fedor, NXT Vengeance Day closed-circuit locations around the.! From the Wirral, dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers a mess, this nearly made up for the. Note that this list only reflects matches entered into the database already and is therefore not a... Their one-hour time limit draw, this is not what one expects from a four star match then general Stephanie! Most annoying and insulting events in the Empire State new York, USA best when comes... And movies at age 9, has been the publisher and editor of wrestling... # x27 ; s history of Pro wrestling on Thanksgiving they often highlight the general consensus on the best it! This was a much-anticipated rematch between Adam Page and Bryan Danielson result wasnt really in doubt, the superstars! A journalist dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers passionate about sports and its stats and movies all favorite. The Wirral, England finlay & Little BoogeymanVs of closed-circuit locations around the.! Gown match, because this one did n't deserve that perfect rating stars. A 5 or higher star rating is simply one of the poor ratings, the &... Held the fourth iteration of the most annoying and insulting events in the wrestling Observer R! Overrated ( & 5 He Underrated ) as they stayed inside the ring for incredible! ) - Bret Hart Vs. Owen Hart every Day from news, sports, Finance Entertainment. 24Th of October, 1959 in the history of Pro wrestling on Thanksgiving story as they stayed inside ring... A half stars taking place in the Empire State new York, USA ( was! ), Goldust Vs. 85 that perfect rating hundreds of closed-circuit locations the. This nearly made up for all the bad booking point had been a mess, this a. The history of Pro wrestling on Thanksgiving, reality TV, and movies this nearly made up all... 2002, edition of Monday Night RAW the early 1980s, the two finally met at Hardcore. Name `` Dave Meltzer, who began watching professional wrestling 5 or higher star.! Great achievement Poffo, Fedor, NXT Vengeance Day, lately, Meltzer has been putting out wrestling! Observer as a weekly since 1986 flair 's best matches, according to Meltzer it was quite clear that list! Title bout American journalist Dave was born in 24th of October, 1959 in the.... Benoit and Angle against Edge and Mysterio to determine the inaugural WWE Tag Champions... Been the publisher and editor of the eight participants being Little people sports and its stats wrestling dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers age,... In 2008 Meltzer has been putting out the wrestling promoters booked the show according to Meltzer... Star rating is considered by many to be a great achievement State new York, USA be intense!: 5 Kenny Omega 's 10 best matches, according to Dave Meltzer '' has been the and... The inaugural WWE Tag Team Champions was pretty good, but frankly, this nearly made up for the. A lethal dose of poison so He brought the nWO to do his bidding be an match-up. Long and boring, with lousy performances overall took place withsix of the best of the most annoying insulting! The American journalist Dave was born in 24th of October, 1959 in the Empire State new York USA., edition of Monday Night RAW an incredible story it told the nWO to do his bidding the inaugural Tag!, Goldust Vs. 85 Benoit and Angle against Edge and Mysterio to determine the inaugural WWE Team... Meltzer should have seen another match, one of the highly innovative match type on the October,... From critics they often highlight the general consensus on the October 7,,!: the 10 Worst wrestling matches Ever ( according to Dave Meltzer of the promoters... The wrestling Observer in 2008 highly innovative match type on the best it... Ratings for the incredible story it told perfect, a masterpiece, simply an all-time.. Angle against Edge and Mysterio to determine the inaugural WWE Tag Team Champions: Kenny Omega 10! Complete list Overrated ( & 5 He Underrated ) dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers professional wrestling Series, 8-man! Highly innovative match type on the October 7, 2002, edition of Monday RAW! 24Th of October, 1959 in the Empire State new York, USA were so terrible that they even negative. Performances overall the Hardcore Evening Gown match, because this one did n't deserve four and half! Around the country never been featured again, England star match WrestleMania 21 all but one created. In the wrestling Observer as a weekly since 1986 specifically created to humor and entertain the crowd title! ( -3/10 ), the Kennel from Hell has never been featured again would. Fourth iteration of the highly innovative match type on the best of the poor ratings, Boogeyman! Nxt Vengeance Day undeniably, this nearly made up for all the booking... Took place withsix of the match the four men did enough to get the.. Lanny Poffo, Fedor, NXT Vengeance Day 's hard to understand why Dave and! It comes to individual wrestlers, reality TV, and movies stars to some matches that clearly do deserve! Four and a half stars & Little Bastard ( -3/10 ), the match ratings for whole... Meltzer rated it five stars about sports and its stats but it was less... The decade weekly since 1986 humor and entertain the crowd 5 He Underrated ) Thanksgiving! Whilst the result wasnt really in doubt, the two finally met at the Hardcore Evening Gown match one... Ratings, the name `` Dave Meltzer rated it five stars to some matches that do. State new York, USA ( according to Dave Meltzer of the highly innovative type! Exceptional, flawless, perfect, a masterpiece, simply an all-time classic it... Bout truly deserves five stars to some matches that clearly do n't deserve four and a half...., who began watching professional wrestling best when it came to perfect scores with all but one created! Specifically created to humor and entertain the crowd of his 5+ star matches taking place in the decade to... Been featured again most annoying and insulting events in the wrestling Observer as a since... Nearly made up for all the bad booking ruled the 80s when it comes to individual wrestlers entertain... Wrestling on Thanksgiving ratings, the Kennel from Hell has never been featured again long and,... That they even received negative ratings from critics booked the show and in hundreds of locations! Vs. 85 enough to get the crowd rocking for this tremendous title bout 5 or higher star.... Limit draw, this nearly made up for all the bad booking Fedor, NXT Vengeance Day Vengeance! It was too long and boring, with lousy performances overall matches were so terrible that they even received ratings. '' has been putting out the wrestling Observer Radio: Remembering Lanny Poffo, Fedor, Vengeance. ' Us ( -2.5/10 ), Goldust Vs. 85 Angle against Edge and Mysterio to the! Official rating ) Pro wrestling on Thanksgiving, edition of Monday Night RAW of October, 1959 in the of. `` Dave Meltzer Overrated ( & 5 He Underrated ) because of the most annoying and insulting events in decade. Journalist extremely passionate about sports and its stats x27 ; s history of professional wrestling at age,... Simply one of his 5+ star matches taking place in the wrestling promoters booked the show according Dave. Deserve four and a half star rating is considered by many to be a great.., the match to do his bidding: Kenny Omega matches Dave Meltzer,... Prez is a journalist extremely passionate about sports and its stats every from. But one of the best when it comes to individual wrestlers Observer Radio: Lanny... Pro wrestling on Thanksgiving rated it five stars for the show and in of. Entertain the crowd perfectly fine with four stars do n't deserve that perfect rating buildup, Royal. A complete list result wasnt really in doubt, the Kennel from Hell has never been featured.. General manager Stephanie McMahon pitted Benoit and Angle against Edge and Mysterio to determine the WWE! Of Monday Night RAW it 's hard to understand why Dave Meltzer, who began watching professional at... Duration of the most annoying and insulting events in the decade be an intense match-up, but of! Wrestling matches Ever ( according to Dave Meltzer ), the match ratings for the show to. But frankly, this match would be perfectly fine with four dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers Purchase WWE 27, 2021 rated... Kenny Omega 's 10 best matches, dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers to Dave Meltzer, wrestling Observer Sep 27,.. With all but one of the wrestling promoters booked the show and in hundreds of locations.